"Sherlock, episode 4x01: The Six Thatchers“ Starring: Benedict Cumberbatch, Martin Freeman, Rupert Graves, Jonathan Aris, Mark Gatiss, Una Stubbs, Louise Brealey, Amanda Abbington Previously on Sherlock: Sherlock killed a guy to protect John and Mary because he promised he would and Mycroft talked the British government into sparing him whatever prison sentence in favor of sending him off on some suicide mission that was cut short when Moriarty appeared on every television screen in England. Or at least the London area. Presumably because he knew he was headed to his death, Sherlock did enough drugs to kill a small horse before he got on the plane, which Mycroft claims is why his trip into his mind palace to solve the mystery of how Moriarty could possibly have survived being shot in the head was trippier than usual (although it didn't look any worse than the time he was dying). We open on some shaky footage of Sherlock shooting Magnusson, which Mycroft is showing to the same people he had to convince to send Sherlock on that mission instead of just locking him up and throwing away the key. He says it's "beyond top secret", so the woman who takes minutes cannot record anything. The only people allowed to know about this are in the room and have the codenames Antarctica, Langdale, Porlock and Love. Chrissy: I assume since he's so warm and cuddly that Mycroft is Antarctica. Diandra: That would probably depend on who chose the names. Sherlock is sitting next to him tapping away on his phone, the keyboard clicking noise playing loudly because apparently he took it off mute for some reason. Mycroft stops talking midsentence to bark "are you TWEETING" at him. He jumps and flips his phone over like a kid caught with his hand in the cookie jar and says "no! Of course I'm not tweeting. Why would I be tweeting?" Mycroft wrestles the phone from his hand and reads "back on terra firma. Free as a bird." Sherlock grumbles that he's being a spoilsport. Mycroft snaps at him to try to take this seriously. Sherlock asks what makes him think he isn't taking it seriously. "Hashtag oh what a beautiful morning," Mycroft reads dryly. Sherlock defensively says that he was JUST sent on a mission that was guaranteed to kill him. And now here he is, back home safely and...he gets distracted when he notices the plate of ginger snaps (nuts in Britain) on a table and goes to grab a handful. Oh, and he's still riding a massive high. Lady Smallwood (remember her?) notes that the doctors said he was clean. Yeah, you might want to check their credentials again. Sherlock, between mouthfuls of cookies, says he is and he doesn't need stimulants anymore now that he has work again. This is a natural high that comes from seeing your life flash before your eyes (because you took enough stimulants to stop your heart at least twice) and surviving. Then he sings (sort of) that he's just glad to be alive and starts rambling about what the other people in the room would do on such a lovely day. This goes on until Lady Smallwood's patience runs out and she snaps "Mr. Holmes", which, of course, both brothers respond to. Mycroft plays the video again, which has been edited so that it looks like Sherlock never actually raised the gun in his hand. Sherlock asks who shot Magnusson then. The guy who isn't Mycroft says it was some overenthusiastic sniper. Sherlock sniffs that that's not what happened at all. Mycroft says as far as anyone knows, it IS what happened. The guy says they have some very talented people working for them and if James Moriarty can hack into every broadcast channel in the country, they can edit a damn video. THAT is now the official version of the video they will be circulating to whoever asks what happened. So, Lady Smallwood notes, he doesn't actually need an official pardon anymore. As far as anyone knows, he did nothing. Sherlock, who has been tossing pieces of ginger nut into his mouth and chewing twitchily the entire conversation, jams the last cookie in his mouth and jumps up like he's going to run for it before they change their mind. Lady Smallwood is like hold up...you said Moriarty filmed that message before he died, but you "know what he's going to do next". Other guy suggests this was the extent of it: random fearmongering from a terrorist. Sherlock says nah, that would be too pedestrian for him. He planned something far more long term and elaborate. A sort of dead man's switch in case he didn't make it off the roof. Chrissy: Or, you know...somebody else who is still alive was behind him the entire time and he was just doing their bidding. Diandra: Let's not address that character assassination until we absolutely have to, hmm? Lady Smallwood reminds him that THIS is what they brought him back for and asks what he plans to do. Sherlock says since he's the target all he has to do is wait. The trouble will eventually come to him. Credits. We come back to some footage of an aquarium. Specifically, the sharks. Sherlock voiceovers a story about a Persian merchant meeting a surprised Death at the market in Bagdad. Of course, the merchant was scared out of his mind and ran like hell all the way to Samarra, only to find Death waiting there for him. Rather than trying to run to another city, he accepted his fate, but wanted to know why Death was so surprised to see him in the market. "Because I had an appointment with you tonight in Samarra," Death said. This is the paradox that makes all time travel stories a bitch. Sherlock stabs a whole stack of papers into the mantle over the fireplace, noting that at this rate, he's going to need another knife. He frowns at John, tapping on his computer, but doesn't comment on the fact that he is clearly just massaging the keyboard and the screen is stuck on a Microsoft Paint image of his blog because this is the first sign that the people behind this show aren't really even trying this season. Mary is pacing and looking uncomfortable. She asks what Sherlock is planning to do about Moriarty then. Sherlock flops into his chair, tapping away at his phone, while he explains that he's going to...um...monitor the situation and wait for Moriarty's next move. Hovertext says he is Tweeting again with the hashtag 221bringit! John notes that his plan is basically to just sit around solving crimes like he always did. Chrissy: I mean, it's like you think this show is about CASES or something. Diandra: I know, right? Ridiculous. Sherlock smirks at him like 'yep!' and grabs a sheet from the knife. Montage of cases featuring flashes of blog entries that were apparently never actually made. Sherlock is tapping away noisily on his phone the entire time. First woman says they thought her...husband...somebody...drowned, but when the coroner's office opened his lungs they found sand. Sherlock declares it "superficial" and they move on with no explanation. The next one has Sherlock inspecting a bag full of ice and a dismembered finger. Sherlock calls for somebody to come back because "it's the wrong thumb". A door slams downstairs. Next is a guy who manages to be in two places at once and dead in one of them. But Sherlock still insists it can't be twins because "it's never twins" is a running joke now. Then he has an inspector (the guy from the episode nobody liked and who probably nobody remembers) and a coroner on split screen video chat, solving two cases at once, one of which seems to be the case that was mentioned at the beginning of "The Abominable Bride" of the dismembered body. While he's doing this, he's STILL tapping away at his phone. John and Mary both try to get his attention because they are concerned about all this burning the candle at both ends he's doing. Cut to him telling a client that he killed his own brother and doesn't remember because his medication causes amnesia. He's still tapping on his phone. Possibly taking notes and thinking about how he could alter this guy's strategy successfully should he ever need to get rid of his own brother. Both John and Sherlock arrive home, laughing about something having to do with a jellyfish, and John realizes he has fifty- nine missed calls on his phone. From Mary. "We're in trouble," Sherlock concludes. And then we jump right to John speeding a car toward the hospital and trying to coach Mary, screaming in the back, through lamaze breathing. He glares at Sherlock, who is sitting next to Mary tapping away at his phone, and Sherlock belatedly jumps in to coach her. She snarls at him and slams his face into the window. He is still somehow tapping on his phone. Mary yells at John to pull over NOW and screams and Sherlock looks at her lap, wide-eyed. And then we're at the Watson house and Mrs. Hudson is taking pictures of them with the baby while Molly drinks champagne. Sherlock is standing in the corner staring at his phone. Mrs. Hudson asks what the baby's name is. John says "Catherine". Mary says no, they changed their minds about that. "Have we," John asks. Sherlock reminds them that they already have his two cents on the matter and they both snap that Sherlock is NOT a girl's name. John tells Mrs. Hudson and Molly that they would like them to be godparents. Then, after a hesitation, John says "you too, Sherlock." Sherlock doesn't look up as he says 'hmm? whatsat?' John says he'd like him to be the baby's godfather. "God is a ludicrous fiction dreamt up by inadequates who abdicate all responsibility to an invisible magic friend," Sherlock grumbles while apparently solving three more cases via text. John says yeah, but...just do it, okay? Also, there will be cake involved at the ceremony. Chrissy: You mistake him for Mycroft. Diandra: It can't be a shared weakness? So they're all at the christening and Sherlock is STILL goddamn texting. Mary tells the priest that the baby's name is Rosamund Mary. Both Sherlock and John look surprised by this. Molly explains to Sherlock that the name means "rose of the world" and they are calling her "Rosie" for short. Then, after a pause, she adds that it was in the text John sent so he should KNOW that. Sherlock mutters that he deletes his texts, or any text that begins with "hi". Molly snarks that it's a wonder why people think he's incapable of human emotion. Then she directs him to put the damn phone away and he puts it behind his back and continues typing blindly. The priest asks if the godparents are ready to perform their duties. The women both respond and Sherlock stares blankly. Molly elbows him and the British male version of Siri apologizes that he didn't catch that from behind Sherlock's back. John looks annoyed, but nobody is really surprised. And then we're back in 221b where Sherlock is grumbling that "Watson", as usual, sees but does not OBSERVE. He turns to John's chair and continues to blather about how "to you the world is an impenetrable mystery whereas to me it is an open book. Hard logic versus romantic whimsy. You fail to connect actions to their consequences. Now, for the last time, if you want to keep the rattle, do not throw the rattle." We switch view to show Rosie sitting in her dad's chair in some sort of baby seat. Sherlock hands her the aforementioned toy and we cut back to his face as she chucks it into his nose. Rosie giggles happily. Chrissy: That's my girl. Diandra: Yeah, see if you're still laughing when her first word is "idiot". None of this wakes up John and Mary, who are passed out in a heap on the couch on the other side of the room. We cut to John sitting on a bus, his eyes still closed, so if your chosen method of dealing with the general fuckery that is this season is to believe that it is all happening in John's head somehow or we are in some sideways world where the old rules no longer apply, now would be the point where that break would occur. Because in hindsight, this is the point when everything started to go sideways. John is startled awake by his phone buzzing. He pulls up a message from Sherlock asking him to come around 221b tomorrow at five because Lestrade says he has a case for them. John doesn't respond, so Sherlock sends a follow up: "Mary says it's okay." Chrissy: Good of you to check with the boss first. You're learning. Diandra: I thought I was Mary. Chrissy: Yeah, well, you were too slow to respond. John puts the phone away, then catches a striking redhead smiling at him. He becomes self conscious immediately, fussing with his hair and sneaking glances at her. She is playing with a piece of paper in her lap. The bus stops and John gets off. He catches sight of himself in one of the windows of the bus and realizes he still has a flower in his hair that he put behind his ear while he was diapering Rosie earlier. He takes it out as the bus drives away. 221b. Um...I guess it's the next day already. Lestrade fills him in on the details of the case he promised would be a "good one". We see the events in flashback. Some guy named David Welsborough had a 50th birthday party at the mansion he apparently lives in. He and his wife have an inane little conversation to establish how very much in love with each other they still are. Then the wife complains that that bust of Margaret Thatcher on the table in the room they just moved into is "looking at me disapprovingly again". Chrissy: Nothing personal. She looked at everyone that way. Diandra: Except possibly Ronald Regan which tells you everything you need to know about her. David's phone buzzes and he takes the call over his wife's objections. She softens when she sees it's coming through Skype, which means "it must be Charlie". A twenty-something appears on his screen (and suspended beside them for the audience) with a mountain scene in the background and says "hi dad!" The connection starts breaking up immediately as he wishes dad a happy birthday and apologizes for missing the party. The image freezes entirely and cuts out. Charlie apologizes for the terrible signal, but says he can still hear him. David puts the phone to his ear and asks where Charlie is anyway. Mom, not liking being cut off, does the standard mom questions, demanding David ask if he's eating properly. Yeah. He's a guy. My dad once told me that when he was living on his own his idea of "healthy eating" was pouring dressing over a head of lettuce and eating it over the sink. Someone calls them (her name is Emma, apparently) and David moves away to find a quieter place. Charlie is slow to respond now, though, and says he's a bit..."nothing. Probably it's the altitude." He reminds dad he's in Tibet. Then he asks if dad can do him a favor and go check something on his car. "The guys here don't believe I've got a Power Ranger stuck to the bonnet. Could you take a photo and send it?" Dad goes out to the car and takes a picture of the blue Power Ranger figure jammed over the Ford logo. He hits send and asks if Charlie got it. There's no response. He assumes the connection died and hangs up. Lestrade says the weird part comes a week later when a drunk driver smashed into that car, still in front of the house, after being chased by some cops. The car, either because it's in TV land or because it's a Ford, explodes in an enormous fireball. Lestrade says the drunk guy survived, but after the fire was put out, they found a body in the parked car. DNA tests verified that it was Charlie, the son who was supposedly in Tibet. And it was empty the night of the party. Sherlock, eyes closed and in thinking pose, chuckles. John asks for the lab report. Lestrade digs it out while he adds that David is a cabinet minister, so there's kind of a lot of pressure to solve this case. Sherlock grumbles that nobody cares about that part and asks for more details on the seats of the car. He snatches another report from Lestrade and reads that two different types of vinyl were found. He asks if it was Charlie's actual car. Lestrade says yeah, it was nothing fancy because he was a student. Sherlock notes that vinyl is cheaper than leather. Lestrade blinks at him like yeah...okay... John pipes up that according to the autopsy, Charlie had been dead a week before the fire. "Oh, this IS a good one," Sherlock chortles. "Is it my birthday?" Chrissy: Are...are you actually asking? I can't tell. Diandra: Well, since this season is all about changing everything that was previously agreed upon by generations of Sherlock Holmes fans, it's quite possible he doesn't actually know when it is anymore. Sherlock says he'll help on one condition: that Lestrade takes all the credit because "it gets boring if I just solve them all." Lestrade grumbles that he says that and then John puts it in his blog and he gets all the credit anyway, making Lestrade look like "some sort of prima donna who insists on getting credit for something he didn't do." Chrissy: And we all know if anyone here fits that description, it would be YOU. Diandra: Are you calling me a drama queen again? Chrissy: If the shoe fits, dear. John smirks and notes that Sherlock has hit some sort of "sore spot". Sherlock sighs and says FINE he'll take all the credit. Again. Chrissy: You think maybe he does this as some sort of reverse psychology? Diandra: Probably. It's probably more that this is an attempt to reference the original stories that doesn't quite work. Doyle's stories had John writing them some years AFTER the cases were finished. So whichever investigator was working the case took credit at the time and John outed Sherlock as the real brains behind it long after the fact. Chrissy: Too bad that's all he outed him for. Diandra: Yeah, I regretted that word choice the second I said it. Sherlock says yeah, sure, he'll solve it. He calls Lestrade "Giles" and everyone kind of freezes like 'seriously?' Sherlock grins, says he's just kidding, then mouths "what is it" at John. John mouths back "GREG" twice and they both pretend they weren't just doing that when Lestrade looks up from putting the papers back in his briefcase. John says it's kind of obvious what happened, isn't it? Sherlock says oh, really? He's solved it then? John says no, he was just expecting Sherlock to say that because this is usually the point where he does. Sherlock gets up to get his coat and pointedly calls Lestrade "Greg". Lestrade and John smile like 'see? he figured it out eventually.' This probably making Lestrade think of training a small child, he asks John how things are with Rosie. John says it's great. Lestrade asks if he's getting any sleep. "Christ, no," John says flatly. "You at the beck and call of a screaming, demanding baby, woken up all hours to obey his every whim? Must feel very different," he says, staring at Sherlock pointedly. Sherlock is like 'huh? what? but I thought the baby was a girl...' Chrissy: Yes, he is. Diandra: Really, John? Really? Chrissy: Sorry, that sounded sexist, didn't it? You're not a girl. But refer back to previous conversations re: you being a drama queen. John continues the joke as they go down the stairs, saying it's all about cleaning up their messes and patting them on the head. Sherlock is like 'okay, seriously, what is this?' John pretends he can't hear him. And they NEVER say thank you. Lestrade piles on with "it's all 'oh, aren't you so clever?'" Sherlock stops and asks if this is some sort of joke and if it's about him. Lestrade tells John he thinks the big baby needs "winding". John agrees. Sherlock grumbles that he really doesn't get this joke. Chrissy: We know sweetie. It's a good thing you're cute. Diandra: You do remember me saying I had run through scenarios in my head of ways I could kill you and get away with it, right? Chrissy: Yeah. Could have done without that in the best man's speech. So the three of them visit the mansion. As they go inside, Lestrade begs Sherlock to "go easy on them". "You know me," Sherlock blusters. Yeah. Hence why he said that. John is distracted by a phone call from Mary. He answers by swearing he remembered to get the diapers and the cream he was supposed to get for the baby. Mary is like 'yeah, whatever, are you at the dead kid's house yet?' She is standing in the Watson's kitchen, bouncing the baby on her hip distractedly while she asks what sort of theories Sherlock has so far. Because despite what some asshole once told my mother, women CAN, in fact, walk and chew bubble gum at the same time. Specifically, she's wondering if they've got anything more than the two types of vinyl thing. Sherlock grabs the phone from John's hands and demands to know how she knows that much. She says receptionists hear everything. He asks if she's solved it then. She says she's working on it. He says motherhood is slowing her down. She calls him a pig. He smirks and gives the phone back to John. Mary asks what John is planning to call this one. "The Ghost Driver," he says. Sherlock begs him to stop giving them titles. He hates that. John says the readers love them though and he really thinks they should give the people what they want. "No, never do that," Mofftiss say through their Sherlock puppet. "People are stupid." I um...had a comment for that one, but I've decided to just...leave it at that. So they go into the main sitting room and Sherlock greets David and Emma and says he's sorry to hear about their daughter. "Son," John corrects. "Son," Sherlock says like 'that didn't happen and you will NOT put that in the story'. Lestrade introduces them to Sherlock and David says they've heard a lot about him. And you still wanted him to help you? Really? Sherlock is immediately distracted by the shrine to Margaret Thatcher set up on the table (now missing the bust that was looking at Emma disapprovingly). Everything goes watery and ominous like the shark tank has been superimposed over this. After a couple seconds he snaps out of it and tries to refocus on David, except David is just rambling about how Charlie was their whole world and they may never get over this. Sherlock excuses himself and wanders over to the shrine. John follows and asks what's wrong now. Sherlock has no idea, he just has a feeling... John scoffs at this and Sherlock lectures him about intuition being data processed too fast for the mind to fully comprehend. He points at the table and asks David what it is. David, rightly embarrassed, says he was always a fan of "Mrs. T" since he was first getting started in business. Her anti-labor policies really appealed to you, huh? Sherlock says right, yes of course. Sorry, who is this again? David splutters that he can't possibly NOT recognize Margaret Thatcher, the first female Prime Minister of the country. Sherlock says yeah, of course. Wait...what's a Prime Minister? John snaps that Sherlock knows PERFECTLY well who she is (as he demonstrated back in Hounds of Baskerville although now I'm not sure Mofftiss actually remember details like that about previous episodes, so...) and asks why he's stalling. David goes back over to the couch with his wife, annoyed. I'd like to think this is the real reason Sherlock is pretending not to know her (because, as I said, previous episodes show that he DOES know who Margaret Thatcher was). Sherlock mutters to John that there's a gap on the table. Everything is perfectly ordered to the point of OCD. One of the figures is repositioned and the picture straightened after the maid cleans but there's a giant, ugly gap in the middle of it all like something went missing recently. David says yes, there used to be a plaster bust there. Emma snaps that it was broken and this has NOTHING to do with Charlie, so what is the point of it? Sherlock points to the floor and notes that there's a rug underneath it so how could it have simply fallen and broken? Chrissy: Because Emma knocked it so it would land just past the rug? Diandra: The bitch kept GLARING at me! No. Emma repeats that this has nothing to do with what they called him for. John apologizes to her, but says it's worth just letting Sherlock go on whatever tangents he finds because he gets the results in the end. Emma asks if he's "mad". John says no, he's an asshole. David says FINE, they had a break in and some little twerp smashed the bust out on the porch. To add ridiculousness to insult, he bemoans that anyone would hate her so much that they would go through so much trouble to destroy a likeness of her. Yeah. You do remember when she died and the song "Ding Dong the Witch is Dead" saw a massive spike in downloads from the UK, right? Or did you just pretend that wasn't happening and continue to believe everyone loved her because you live in a blissful little conservative bubble that reality can't penetrate? Anyway. Sherlock suggests maybe it had something to do with her face. Ha. Then he wonders why the person didn't smash all the other memorabilia. Like the one where she has that smug smile on her face. Emma starts moaning to Lestrade that this is a waste of time. Sherlock interrupts that he knows what happened to her son. He says it's "simple", perhaps even "superficial". Chrissy: How about elementary? Diandra: Pfffttt. No. I've never said that. He asks for further clarification on the circumstances surrounding the night of the break-in. This room would have been dark, right? And the porch would have been lit? John concludes that the guy who took it needed to break it somewhere where he could see it. Sherlock says yes, but WHY. Emma begs him to get back to the point. He takes a deep breath, turns to her and spews a long explanation about how her son supposedly couldn't come back for his parents' 50th anniversary because he was in Tibet. But the first part of the phone call was pre-recorded. Charlie was in the car the whole time, covered by the second vinyl car seat so he could "surprise" dad when he got close enough. Except that he suffered some sort of seizure - possibly related to whatever was happening that he claimed was "altitude sickness" - and died before he could spring the surprise. Because nobody had any reason to check the car for the next week, nobody noticed until someone happened to crash into it and set it on fire, melting the top seat cover and revealing Charlie's dead body. Emma cries and Sherlock excuses himself to go check the porch where the bust was broken. Lestrade and John follow behind him and John asks what the HELL is so important about this bust. Sherlock says he can't stand loose threads. Chrissy: Well, you're REALLY not going to like the third episode then. He announces that he's taking the car and the two of them can catch a bus. John asks why. Sherlock says he has to concentrate "and I don't want to hit you." Chrissy: Notice how I don't question how those two concepts are related? Diandra: I said I was sorry about that. When are you going to stop bringing it up? Mycroft's dungeon. Seriously, that's what it looks like. Mycroft says he met Thatcher once. He thought she was arrogant, which is really something coming from him. He asks why he's looking at this picture on his phone. Sherlock says it's a picture of John and Mary's baby. Mycroft says oh! Yes! "Looks very.......fully functioning." Chrissy: Why the hell did we send him a picture? Diandra: Sorry. Forgot he was in the contacts. Sherlock asks if that's really the best he can do. Yes. Why are you surprised? Mycroft says he was never good with "them". "Babies," Sherlock asks. "Humans." Chrissy: You know, we keep joking that you're Sherlock, but I think you might have a little Mycroft in you too. Diandra: I am NOT that bad. Chrissy: Oh? So that wasn't you grumbling about a friend proudly showing off pictures of her hideous baby? And making the joke about "are you sure it's fully cooked"? Diandra: It was a newborn. All newborns are hideous. They need a month or two to stop looking like Mandrakes. And stop stalking me on Twitter. Sherlock asks if Moriarty had any sort of connection with or interest in Margaret Thatcher. Mycroft thinks that's a ridiculous question. But he humors Sherlock to say that in the last year he was alive, Moriarty was involved in four political assassinations, 70 plus robberies and terrorist attacks "including a chemical weapons factory in North Korea." Chrissy: Ugh. The Brits are using North Korea as the generic bad guy factory too? Diandra: Isn't everybody outside of Asia? Oh, and he was showing interest in tracking down the "Black Pearl of the Borgias". He notes that that is still missing just in case Sherlock wanted to do something USEFUL. "It's a pearl. Get another one," Sherlock grumbles. Mycroft rolls his eyes. The water effect thing starts again because that will be a theme throughout this season apparently and Sherlock mutters that there's something important about this. "Something's coming." Mycroft frowns and asks what the hell that's about. Is he having a premonition? Sherlock shakes himself and spews some nonsense about premonition just being the interactions of the billions of people and their collective consciousness and if you could quantify that you could totally predict the future. Or something. Honestly, I'm not sure I can bring myself to try to make sense out of anything on this show anymore. Mycroft starts talking about the Samarra story. He says Sherlock always hated that story as a child. In fact, he re- wrote the ending once so that the merchant wound up in another city entirely and survived. Chrissy: And he writes fanfiction to correct things he doesn't like in a story. Okay, the similarities between you and him are getting scary. Sherlock is like 'okay, we're done here'. "Then he becomes a pirate for some reason," Mycroft continues. Chrissy: Yep. Definitely fanfiction. Diandra: I want to know which of the writers are pulling this from their own personal experience because you KNOW they were doing this as children. Chrissy: Oh, both of them, probably. But Moffat's were probably more likely to feature Deus Ex Machinas in the form of the Doctor rescuing people. Diandra: Definitely. Sherlock grumbles at Mycroft to "keep me informed". Mycroft asks what he's supposed to keep him informed about. Sherlock doesn't know, he just wants out of this conversation. He stomps off and we literally smash to the next scene in a cutaway worthy of somebody's film school project. We pan across the broken pieces of another Thatcher bust, unfortunately still recognizable, and end up on an extreme closeup of a man's eye. He seems to be crying and breathing in a way that suggests he's scared of something. A voice says "ammo". Another statue smashes. And we're outside 221b with a pretty woman we've never met before. Lestrade arrives, greets "Stella" and asks if she's waiting to talk to Sherlock or something. She says he has a client in there. Chrissy: Oh, that's just what he says when he and John are...um... Diandra: Playing Cluedo. Chrissy: You know, I don't think that euphemism is used outside of those Twitter accounts. Nice going getting a bunch of teenagers mad at you for suggesting you would kill Sherlock in a story, by the way. Diandra: Ugh. Don't remind me. Those accounts were fun until the insane fangirls ruined them. Lestrade is like okay, so guess I'm waiting here too then. He tries to make awkward small talk about her still "seeing" Sherlock, which...um...when? What? She says she just "pops round" every so often when she finds a really good case. Lestrade asks what she's here for now. She says Interpol is still fretting over that Black Pearl thing... Chrissy: Borgia Pearl. Diandra: Yeah, well...that won't be the last time I do that. They think it traces back to London. She redirects to ask how he and Greg first met. Lestrade says it was ten years ago where an old lady died of hypothermia inside a sauna. Don't bother checking the Doyle cannon to see if that's some sort of Easter egg. It's not. However, the rest of this episode is pretty faithful to "The Six Napoleons", which I'm surprised to find Mofftiss actually read since they misidentified a quote from it in the commentary of a previous episode. Sherlock opens the door and yells at them to be quiet, then slams it again. The detectives act like children who have been banished to a corner. Inside, Sherlock continues whatever conversation he was supposedly having with the client, expositing that he wasn't always in life insurance. He used to be a manual laborer, as evidenced by the fact that his dominant hand is significantly larger than the non-dominant. The client says he was a carpenter just like his father. Sherlock, barely listening, adds that he's unsuccessfully trying to give up smoking and he once had a Japanese girlfriend that he is now indifferent to. Chrissy: What have we said about showing off? Diandra: I don't know, I wasn't listening. The client looks down at the e-cigarettes in his pocket and says oh...that. Sherlock says there are TEN of them and if he was just using e-cigarettes because he wanted to smoke indoors he would use "one of those irritating electronic pipe things", but that would be admitting defeat and he really is determined to quit. So he keeps buying individual ones because he's sure each one will be the last. "Anything to add, John?" Sherlock looks at John's chair and jumps a little as he realizes there is nothing there but a red balloon with a face drawn on it in sharpie. "John," he asks and the thought bubble over his head says "I didn't take any drugs today, why am I hallucinating? Please tell me I'm not the only one seeing this!" John sticks his head out from around the corner dividing the sitting room from the kitchen, coffee cup in hand, and says yes, he's listening. "What is that," Sherlock demands to know. John says it's a substitute for him. You know, since he's basically a replacement for the skull on the mantelpiece and Sherlock doesn't even notice whether he's there or not before he starts talking. Sherlock acts embarrassed and says "don't be so hard on yourself. You know I value your...little... contributions." John notes that the balloon has been sitting there since 9am. Sherlock asks where John was then. John says he was helping Mrs. Hudson with her sudoku. Jesus, how many hours did that take? It's really not THAT difficult. The client tries to redirect Sherlock back to him by asking how he knew about the girlfriend thing. Sherlock says oh, he has a Japanese looking tattoo on his arm with the name "Akako" that he's tried to have removed. The client notes that that would suggest he was trying to FORGET her, wouldn't it? Sherlock thinks in that case he would have "obliterated" the name entirely, but since the first attempt to remove the tattoo didn't work and he hasn't tried again he obviously decided he just doesn't give a shit and he can live with the reminder. The client laughs and says basically that he thought Sherlock was some sort of wizard, but now that he's explained it it's actually pretty obvious. Sherlock takes a deep breath and glares at the client like 'I could murder you and my brother would bury the evidence.' He launches into a monologue about how the client thought his wife was having an affair (apparently the reason he came in the first place) because, honestly, he's out of her league anyway but she's really a Swedish spy named Greta Bengsdotter. In fact, she's the most dangerous spy in the world and she's been undercover for four years to get close to the American Embassy across the street from his flat in an insane plot to inject the American president with a new drug that will render him the puppet of criminal mastermind James Moriarty. At that point, Moriarty will use him to destabilize the United Nations before the vote on nuclear non-proliferation and start a chain of events that will inevitably lead to world war three. Chrissy: There should be a scroll running across the bottom of this scene noting that nobody knew at the time this was written or filmed that the new president of the United States would be the moron puppet of a shady foreigner who doesn't need to be drugged to believe completely crazy bullshit and lead us into World War Three. Diandra: Yeah, but I feel like that might give Mofftiss the false impression that they are prophetic or something. John laughs and asks "you serious?" like he knows the answer already. Sherlock says no, of course his wife left him because he has horrible halitosis and he likes to wear her lingerie. The guy whimpers that he does NOT. Well...just the bras... Sherlock stomps over to the door and holds it open, ordering the guy to leave. Then he slams the door on the guy's back like Lestrade and that other woman aren't still out there waiting to talk to him. John asks what all of "this" is about. Sherlock says he's having fun. "While I can." Chrissy: Before Mofftiss take it all away from me. The woman knocks before letting herself in, babbling that she just needs to talk to Sherlock about... "Borgia Pearl. Boring. Go," Sherlock interrupts, shoving her out the door and slamming it. Lestrade opens it again and Sherlock grumbles that this one had better be good. Lestrade holds up an evidence back full of broken pieces of Margaret Thatcher's face. He says this is a different one belonging to a different owner in a completely different part of town. Are there a lot of people who would own one of those? In 2015? Really? Sherlock stares at the pieces and the special effects department blows part of the budget for all three episodes on an effect to superimpose a piece of the bust over his face for no reason whatsoever. I mean, it's neat, but I will be bringing this up again when I question their ability to budget appropriately later. "The game is on," he says because we have to figure out a way to work that line in at least once an episode now. Sherlock inspects the broken pieces under his microscope while Lestrade says there's actually been TWO more broken statues, one belonging to Mohandes Hassan, the other to a Doctor Barnicot. John notes that they're not just busts of the same person, they're the SAME bust. Lestrade doesn't understand this oddly specific behavior. John suggests the person who did it is one of those people who gets an idea in their head and just CAN'T LET IT GO. He looks very pointedly at Sherlock as he says this. Sherlock of course misses the significance of that and points out that there were other pictures of this woman - Margaret, was it? - at the first scene that were untouched. Seriously, is this pretending he doesn't know who she is thing supposed to be a running joke? Why? Chrissy: You need to stop assuming there is a rhyme and reason to the things television writers do. Diandra: I just...aaarrrrrrrgggggghhhh. He finds blood on one of the pieces and asks Lestrade if anyone was injured. Lestrade says no, so Sherlock concludes the suspect must have cut themselves while they were breaking the statue. He shoves the bloodied piece in a bag and announces that they're going to Lambeth to see Toby. John pretends to know what he's talking about for a half a second, then asks who Toby is. Sherlock just says wait and see and John, obviously long ago having recognized the pointlessness of trying to get answers out of him, just goes along with it. He asks if Lestrade is coming. Sherlock says he isn't because he has a lunch date with a brunette forensic officer, which is why he has been looking at his watch approximately every five seconds since he came through the door. Lestrade asks who told him that like he hasn't known Sherlock for a decade and should have stopped asking shit like that long ago. Sherlock points out the hairs on his jacket, the smell of formaldehyde coming off him and the blatantly obvious watch thing. Lestrade goes to leave and Sherlock, tapping away on his phone again, mutters that she's not right for him though. Lestrade is like yeah, fuck off. John asks what makes him say that after Lestrade is out of earshot. Sherlock says she has three children in Rio Lestrade doesn't know about. John asks if he's making that part up. "Possibly," Sherlock says. And then John asks who Toby is again, blowing my theory that maybe he's learned something from the last few years. Chrissy: If he had he wouldn't still BE here. Diandra: Good point. As we montage our way to a flat in Lambeth, Sherlock rambles about a hacker kid he knows who got in trouble with the Americans a couple years ago by hacking into the Pentagon. Somehow Sherlock managed to get the charge cleared, so he owes him a favor. John asks how a hacker is supposed to help them. Sherlock is like 'note the fact that I never said his name.' A chubby guy with clunky glasses opens the door and Sherlock greets him as Craig. Then he introduces John to Toby, the bloodhound who slinks out the door behind him. And then Mary sticks her head out, holding Rosie who is wearing a bright pink bunny outfit. Or something with ears anyway. John splutters and says they agreed they wouldn't take the baby on a case. Mary says yes, they did. She hands Rosie over to him and tells him not to wait up. Sherlock confirms that he's taking her along because "she's better at this than you." John bristles. Sherlock is like 'come on, she was a secret agent bad ass. Duh.' "Nothing personal." John asks if he's just supposed to go home then. They have an odd few lines of banter where Mary asks if they should take him along and Sherlock asks if she means John or the dog and Mary describes John as "handy and loyal" and are we trying to kill screen time or something here? John thinks all this sarcasm is hilarious and asks if it's too soon to ask for a divorce. And now we come to the first sign that this season was cursed from the start. Every interview with anyone involved with this scene noted that the dog playing Toby was spectacularly uncooperative. Sweet and perfectly friendly if the pictures of Amanda hugging and kissing him are any indication, but stubborn and immovable. So the sequence where Toby drags Sherlock on the trail of a scent turned into some awkwardly edited shots of the dog plodding along slowly at Amanda's coaxing or just because Benedict is running beside him, a possibly different dog entirely running with a GoPro attached to him, the three of them walking with the leash out of frame so we can't see the crew member monkey-shuffling while tugging the other end and the following little interlude. Sherlock, John (with the baby in a bjorn) and Mary (holding the leash) stand beside a phone booth, noting that the dog isn't moving. Sherlock insists he's "thinking". The dog whines and Amanda scratches his head to reassure him. "Slow, but sure, John. Not dissimilar to yourself." "You just like this dog, don't you," John asks. "Well, I like you," Sherlock retorts. Yeah. This is what happens when you have to rewrite a scene at the last possible minute. At some point in there, Sherlock and Mary have an awkward ADR conversation about why the Thatcher busts were specifically targeted. They wind up in a covered marketplace, where Toby loses the scent to all the meat smells. Mary and John both realize that this is the perfect place to hide in a crowd and cover tracks. Sherlock scratches Toby's ears and says "better luck next time." But he adds that this is "the one". He can feel it. "Not Moriarty," John scoffs. Chrissy: You ever feel like sometimes they're skipping crucial parts of conversations? Diandra: Yes, it IS possible Moriarty has a living relative determined to continue his work, but it can't be a twin because it's NEVER TWINS. Chrissy: Like that, yes. Sherlock says it's just too BIZARRE and "barock" (do Brits really pronounce baroque this way?). Whoever is doing it is teasing him, luring him in with something that is just TOO TEMPTING for him to ignore. Dude? It's broken statues. If he's going from strapping bombs to people and making you solve puzzles to free them to petty vandalism of Margaret Thatcher statues then he is REALLY slacking in the psycho foreplay department. We get a brief cutaway to gloved hands breaking a couple more statues. My new theory is that Mofftiss adapted "The Six Napoleons" this way just so they would have an excuse to break a bunch of Margaret Thatcher busts. It's certainly cathartic to watch. And we're at the Watson's residence. John and Mary are lying in bed, talking about their day. SOME day, anyway. Certainly can't be the day we just saw because Mary is likening it to a scene from "The Exorcist" and John is asking if Rosie's head was actually spinning around. Mary says no, but she WAS projectile vomiting, so... She jokes that she would think they'd have noticed the 666 on her forehead when she was born. John points out that that is "The Omen", not "The Exorcist" and you can't be the devil and the antichrist at the same time. Rosie wails from the next room and Mary asks if he's sure about that as she drags herself out of bed to go see what she needs. John's phone buzzes and he picks it up. And the flashback that totally wasn't clear it WAS a flashback ends. And we're back with Toby's owner Craig the hacker. Craig is asking if Sherlock heard about that thing in Germany. Sherlock bemoans the vagueness of that question. Craig says there's this psychological phenomenon wherein people are missing the "good old days" of Communist rule. Uh-huh. Get back to me in a year or two when they're waxing nostalgic for the Nazis because APPARENTLY THAT'S A THING NOW. Anyway, the reason he's thinking about it is because it turns out there's a real market online for Cold War memorabilia. Thatcher statues are just as popular as Regan and Stalin shit. "Time is a great leveler, innit?" Sherlock would like Craig to get to the point faster. Where did the statues come from, exactly? Craig says according to the supplier: Georgia. I'm going to assume since this is England and not the United States that they mean the country. Sherlock needs a more specific location. Tblisi. There were six in that batch and he has the names of all five people who purchased them. Yes, somebody actually deliberately bought TWO creepy ass statues of Margaret Thatcher. Sherlock gets a call from Lestrade and asks if the new one is "Harker or Sandeford". Lestrade says the first one and somebody was murdered this time. Sherlock thinks that really "perks things up". Chrissy: A bit not good. Diandra: Oh, like I'm going to change now? Chrissy: You could at least PRETEND you aren't a psychopath who gets off on people killing each other. Sherlock does some research on the black pearl of Borgia on his phone on the way to the crime scene. What pops across the screen doesn't really tell us anything new. There are no suspects or leads. At the scene, Lestrade explains that the defensive wounds on the victim suggest she fought her attacker before her throat was cut. Sherlock asks if they found the same pattern with the statues inside. Lestrade says yes, and there were two of them. Sherlock fills him in on the limited batch made in Tblisi thing. Lestrade wonders what the point is of destroying them all now. Sherlock doesn't think the point is to destroy them. He barely even glances at the body before announcing that he's headed to find the last bust in Reading owned by a Jack Sandeford. He congratulates Lestrade on his impending solving of a big case and walks away. From the dead body. I know he's sure he can catch the killer by following the same path he is, but this whole thing feels off somehow. So we wind up at an ultra modern, expensive looking house, not unlike Henry's in "Hounds of Baskerville". It's night. Presumably the same night but my sense of time is getting totally fucked up by this episode. A little girl is splashing around in a pool outside, when a man - obviously her dad - comes out to tell her it's time to go to bed. He makes sure to walk past the one remaining statue on his way out. The girl gets out and follows him inside and he turns off all the fancy lights by swooping his hand in front of sensors. Sherlock's silhouette appears outside, where he apparently waits for the next couple hours like a creepy serial killer. Somehow he gets inside by the time the burglar/killer arrives as the second the guy grabs the bust, he turns on the lights and announces that it would be easier to take out his "grievances" in a voting booth. Which...doesn't seem to make any sense in this context, but whatever. I'm starting to think this season will go much easier for me if I stop trying to make sense of it. What they lack in coherent dialogue in this episode, they make up for in action sequences, though, so when the killer turns around waving a gun, they are launched into a fight. After Sherlock gets his face slammed into the kitchen counter enough times to give a normal human a concussion and probably render them unconscious, he rips the guy's face mask off and starts panting his deductions while ducking further punches and kicks. The guy stole something, but he had nowhere to hide it and he was running. So when he wound up in a workshop where some plaster busts were still drying, he figured he'd shove it inside one. Also, Sherlock demonstrates that he DOES know who Thatcher is by calling her the Iron Lady here. So. There's a bit more stilted dialogue that involves Sherlock telling the killer his name for no apparent reason before the killer tackles him through the plate glass window behind him right into the pool outside. They grapple for a while, making several unsuccessful attempts to drown each other, before Sherlock escapes back into the house, retrieves the statue from the killer's bag and clobbers him with it. Then while the guy is groaning on the floor, Sherlock demands he talk about his boss, Moriarty. The guy has no idea who that is. Which...I thought everybody knew about the trial and the taking over all the television thing. Sherlock continues to press this point, leading the killer to think he's a moron. Then Sherlock spikes the statue on the floor himself, declaring Interpol will be thrilled to recover the Black Pearl of the Borgias. Except that it isn't a pearl sitting among the plaster dust, but a flash drive labeled A.G.R.A. You know, like the one Mary gave John and he threw in the fire. Chrissy: This is when I began to suspect this entire season was one long dream sequence or something. Diandra: Yeah, that's why I said the scene earlier was the first breaking off point if you subscribe to the Bobby-Ewing-in-the-shower theory to explain the weirdness of events this season. There will be more, but... Sherlock boggles at it and bends to pick it up while we flash back on Mary handing it to John and John throwing it on the fire. He mutters about this not making sense because "she destroyed it". The killer picks up his gun again and levels it at Sherlock. "You know her?" He says "she" is a bitch who betrayed him. Sherlock, still flailing stupidly, notes that this whole thing has been about Mary. The guy asks if that's what she's calling herself now. He demands Sherlock hand the drive over just as the police arrive outside, sirens wailing. A cop with a bullhorn yells for him to come out with his hands up. He returns that if they try to shoot him, he will kill this guy. And they can see who you're talking about? Can they even hear you? Oh, whatever. They continue the stilted standoff for a while before the killer instructs Sherlock to tell Mary she's a dead woman. Sherlock, totally frozen in confusion apparently, mutters that she's his friend and he is sworn to protect her. The guy is like 'yeah, well...pffffftttt', shoots out the lights and makes a run for it. Chrissy: Dee is paraphrasing and making this sound slightly better than it is, by the way. That whole chunk of dialogue was actually hella awkward. Diandra: Thanks, Chris. And we flash back to Tblisi, six years ago. There is a bizarre hostage scenario playing out in an embassy building. One woman is sitting beside a chess board, making bad jokes about how many moves it will be before checkmate. One of the hostage takers roaming around waves his gun at her threateningly. Turns out she and the other guy at the board really are playing chess to pass time. The guy says they should be sending someone soon. She scoffs at the faith he has in this "they" to get them out. Although she drops a totally unsubtle hint that she has something "they" would love to get their hands on: "Ammo". Before she can say anything else, two people in full secret agent gear drop from the ceiling, opening fire on the hostage takers. Two more agents come through the doors. You know, the easy way. They clear the area and pause while the screen divides and labels them as "A", "G", "R" and "A". "R" goes to help the woman up, calling her "Madam Ambassador". It is clearly Mary's voice. "What took you so long," the woman complains. Well, you're just never happy, are you? The team clear the hostages and take them into a poorly lit underground chamber somewhere where they run into even more of the hostage taker's confederates. The guy we now recognize as the one breaking all the Thatcher statues takes off his mask and asks what they should do now. Mary takes off her mask, says "we die" and throws a flash bomb on the ground. And we're back in the present. Lestrade finds Sherlock standing in the middle of 221b, fidgeting with the drive. He admits they don't have the suspect yet, but he's sure they'll have him soon because he couldn't have gotten far. Sherlock doesn't think so. He starts texting frantically. Elsewhere, the suspect is doing a search for Sherlock Holmes, running through pictures until he finds one from the wedding. He focuses in on Mary's face and flashes back again. He is chased into the workshop with the plaster busts. Things explode in slow motion just for shits and giggles apparently. He takes the flash drive from around his neck and shoves it in the opening at the bottom of one of the busts and is almost immediately captured. We get a quick scene of some burly guys performing some "enhanced interrogation" on him, repeatedly saying "Ammo". He "passes out" and one of the guys asks what he would do if he knew about "the English woman". "What would you do to a traitor," the other guy asks. "Maybe we'll tell him one day," the first guy smarms awkwardly. "If he lives that long." Chrissy: Oh, so this is going to be one of those 'bad guys sit around and reveal information in front of person they think is unconscious for no apparent reason' scenes, huh? Diandra: Yeah, I'm starting to think Mofftiss are using this episode as a trial run for writing the next James Bond or something. I mean...the original Sherlock Holmes story is there, but the majority of this episode is not up to their usual standard. Chrissy: I'm afraid of what episode three is going to look like if we're already complaining this much on episode one. Diandra: I suspect it will just be more of the same except completely unmoored from the original stories. The agent opens his eyes as soon as they leave and drools blood all over himself. He sees shadows move on a wall outside the door as the brutes "interrogate" another prisoner. He falls over, morphs back into the present, and takes a drink of something that looks like maybe Scotch. Mary meets Sherlock at a creepy old church somewhere in a rainstorm. "I am an idiot," he says by way of greeting. "I know nothing." She shrugs off her hood, shakes off some of the rain and says she's been trying to tell him that for a while now. Heh. She notes that that was QUITE the text he sent her. And now that she's here, she would like to know what's going on. He says he was so convinced Moriarty was behind everything that he missed the obvious. He was expecting to find a pearl, but... He holds out the flash drive. She gulps. He notes that it's just like the one she gave John, except it belonged to someone else. He asks who it belonged to. She says she doesn't know, then rambles that they all had one, but the others...has he looked at the contents? Sherlock says yeah, a bit, but he wants to hear it from her because "I'll know the truth when I hear it." She sighs and begins that there were four agents: Alex, Ajay, Gabriel and her. The drives they each had copies of guaranteed their trust in each other because it contained all their real backgrounds and aliases. "We could never be betrayed because we had everything we needed to destroy the other." I'm...trying to understand how that makes sense. Chrissy: Yeah, good luck with that. They were for hire assassins who would work for whoever paid them. But then the coup in Georgia happened. A terrorist takeover of the British embassy. They were sent in, but there was a change of plan at the last minute and they didn't know who it came from. It was just a voice on the phone with the codeword "ammo". They went in, but that whole mess in the last scene happened and she was the only one who escaped in the confusion. She assumed everyone else died. Sherlock plugs the drive into a laptop and pulls up a picture of the guy who was looking for the Thatcher statues. She identifies him as Ajay and starts babbling that she really thought she was the only one and she wants to see him now where is he? Sherlock asks if she kept her stick safe before she gave it to John. She says yes, of course. They made sure to keep them from falling into enemy hands. Sherlock says Ajay hid the memory stick and has been looking for it. But that all happened six years ago. Where has he been and why is he looking for it now? Mary has no idea. Sherlock apologizes and says Ajay wants her dead. She thinks that's ridiculous because they were like family. Sherlock notes that the stick would be the easiest way to track her down. Er...how? It's been in a statue for six years, it's not like the information on it would be current. He just happened to stumble on her current identity through a ridiculous contrivance that caused him to run right into one of the few people who know her AND know who she used to be. Mary thinks he's just trying to find her. Sherlock says no, he said himself that he wants to kill her because she betrayed him. She splutters that that's insane. Then she slumps into a chair and says she always knew on some level that something from her past would come back to haunt her one day. She had hoped she had finally found peace. Sherlock reminds her that he made a vow to look after all three of them. If she sticks close to him, he intends to keep that promise. She blinks, says she'd hoped she wouldn't have to do this, and hands him a piece of paper, instructing him to read it. He opens it, stares at it for a second, then sniffs it and falls over. She helps him down, apologizing, takes the flash drive and asks him, while the room is spinning and wobbling from his perspective, to "look after him till I get back." Sherlock has a brief little dream memory thing that I'm going to completely ignore for now. He comes back, realizes the flash drive is gone and just runs off leaving the laptop and all the burning candles and shit behind. Mycroft's dungeon. Mycroft identifies Agra as a city in Northern India. He lists a couple facts about it while Sherlock stares at him like 'DID I FUCKING ASK?!' Chrissy: Yeah, well. Now you know how the rest of the world feels. "What are you, Wikipedia," he asks. "AGRA's an acronym." Mycroft bristles. Sherlock says furthermore, he knows full well who AGRA is because they were the best agents in the business and he MUST have been aware of them. Two of the members are still alive and the one that isn't Mary is trying to kill her. Mycroft says this part he didn't know, but it's unclear if he's being serious or not. Sherlock summarizes the chase for the memory stick and asks if the British government has anything to do with this. Mycroft babbles about how AGRA used to be reliable until the Tblisi thing. They stopped hiring freelance agents after that. It was too messy. "I don't like loose ends." Chrissy: I see the writers have taken a break from speaking through the characters because that doesn't sound like them. Diandra: It is, however, a running theme of this season apparently. Sherlock grabs a piece of paper and writes "AMMO" on it, presenting it to Mycroft as one more detail in the case. A codeword. He asks Mycroft to do him a favor and look into it. Mycroft asks what he's going to do if he manages to neutralize this threat against Mary. "You think you can go on saving her forever?" Sherlock is arrogant enough to think so, yes. He made a promise. Chrissy: I just realized there might be the potential for a drinking game. Take a sip every time they hammer the same reference over and over. Take two sips when the dialogue turns to repetitive nonsense as a direct or indirect result. Chug when something happens to make you wonder if Mofftiss ever actually READ the original stories or are just basing everything on some movies and the 1980s series with Jeremy Brett. Diandra: Yeah, but if we start now we'll die of liver poisoning. Let's hold off on the drinking until the last episode. I'm pretty sure that's the only way I'm going to get through that one. Mycroft says he'll see what he can do, but reminds Sherlock that there's a reason why agents like Mary tend not to live to retirement age. Sherlock just stubbornly repeats that he's not going to let that happen. At the Watson home, John is reading a letter from Mary. It's literally a Dear John letter. 'I tried to start a new life, but the old one won't leave me alone. I have to go away to protect you both, but I'm not abandoning you, really. I just don't want you and Sherlock fucking up my plans. Love and kisses.' We see Mary on a plane, speaking in a loud, obnoxious New York accent about how she hears a noise and she watched this documentary about why planes crash and the wing is probably going to come off any second and THEY'RE ALL GOING TO DIE but she doesn't like to complain, so. Chrissy: Like a good Jewish mother. Complain constantly and then claim you don't complain. Diandra: Speaking from experience? Chrissy: I plead the fifth. An attendant comes by to ask her to please calm down because everything is fine. Fast forward to her gagging and loudly announcing that she feels awful and she thinks she's dying. The attendant comes back to reassure her. And then somehow, Mary is dressed as the flight attendant when they land, pushing a wheelchair full of the actual attendant dressed in her clothes. Um...how did she manage that in the close quarters of an airplane? Wouldn't it have been easier to find somebody in the airport bathroom and fuck it, I give up. Chrissy: Yeah, it's definitely going to be a long season, isn't it? Mary is still reading the letter in voiceover over the continuing montage, assuring John that there is no use trying to follow her because she is using a dice system to travel around Europe at random so even SHE doesn't know where she's going. She's hoping to draw the "target" as far away from John and Rosie as possible. She'll come back once she's finished. Somewhere in Norway, she finds a hidden American passport with her picture and the name Gabrielle Ashdown. She puts on a dark wig so she looks like the picture in the passport and travels...somewhere else. And then somewhere else where there are palm trees and camels. And then somewhere else that looks Middle Eastern but map claims to be Morocco. She goes into a building where somebody seems to be reading bad terrorist dialogue ripped right from any cheesy spy movie ever. It goes something like 'mwahahahaha you walked right into my trap and now that I have you where I want you I will destroy you and there is nothing you can do to stop me!' Mary realizes this sounds off and frowns before we hear Sherlock's voice announce that he's won whatever game they're playing. Chrissy: So basically a similar gag to the chess/Operation thing last season except much less effective. Diandra: Basically. She comes around the corner and we see him sitting with a teenager. He stops and says "hi, Mary," nonchalantly. "Nice trip?" She stares at him and starts "how the fu..." Sherlock interrupts her to point out that there is a child present and she should probably watch her language. The boy - Karim, apparently - waves at her happily. Sherlock asks him to go get them some tea. Karim does and Mary asks no, really, HOW did he manage to find her. She was choosing aliases and destinations entirely at random. Sherlock blathers that nothing humans do is ever random and anyone can figure anything out if they combine advanced mathematics with understanding of human psychology and the particular habits of one person. He knows at least 58 ways to reduce the number of probable outcomes in a supposedly random array of possibilities. Then after a beat he adds that all of those 58 methods are really hard though, so he just put a tracker in the memory stick. "You bastard," she says as he snort laughs, although really she should have guessed this because a) what kind of spy doesn't check for trackers or bugs and b) they basically had a conversation that followed this exact same template back before the wedding except it was about him learning napkin folding on YouTube. Chrissy: Incidentally, if you were looking for a sign that the writers have gotten lazy...here you go. Diandra: Oh, I'm sure we can find many more and better examples than that. John comes around the corner then to say that actually, the tracker in the memory stick was his idea and her face falls. We cut to the outside view where night is falling so either we're supposed to assume that they've been talking all along or they waited until after dinner or something to continue. John reminds Mary that she told him AGRA was her initials. Chrissy: And here is the sign that the writers actually don't have anything planned out in advance and are totally lying their faces off when they claim they knew all along that this story arc would end with a reveal about Sherlock having a sister who is an evil mastermind batshit crazy Hannibal ripoff. Diandra: Ahem. Yeah. Maybe we should start stocking up on liquor now in preparation for that last episode. Chrissy: [already tapping on her phone, which is open on a shopping list app] Way ahead of you. Mary says yes, well, that was sort of true, wasn't it? John sighs, lists all the other names again and concludes that her real name is Rosamund. She says yeah, Mary is her middle name. She always liked it better. He grumbles that he did too and starts pacing. She's like 'come on, don't be like this.' He snits that she could have STAYED and they could have TALKED and worked things out like a normal married couple. Pffffffftttt. Please. Chrissy: Just because your family routinely needs lawyers to act as moderators of their arguments doesn't mean that's normal. Diandra: Who said anything about my family? Chrissy: ............... Diandra: Sigh. Fine. John says he may not be the greatest man, but he's pretty sure he's better than she gives him credit for. "Most of the time." Chrissy: How about we wait for a verdict on that until we find out what you did with Rosie while you and Sherlock went off on a potentially dangerous mission? She says she never doubted that he was a good man. "You never doubted. You never judge. You never complain. I don't deserve you." Yeah, well, his curse is that he surrounds himself with people who don't deserve him. Just ask the psychopath the camera just revealed has been lurking in the corner this entire conversation for some reason. Mary says she just wanted to keep John and Rosie safe. Sherlock repeats that HE will keep them safe. Chrissy: Drink. He says he can only do that in London though, because he knows the area. He pleads with her to come home. And then a red dot appears on John's head and Sherlock yells for them to get down. Ajay bursts in, shooting randomly. John and Sherlock plaster themselves to the ground while Mary draws her gun and shoots back. They take a break from shooting to talk to each other from around corners. Mary yelps that she really thought he was dead and she was the only one who escaped. Sherlock cuts in to ask how Ajay found them. He holds out his hand for Mary's gun, which she hands over without question. Ajay says he just followed Sherlock. He spews a few more lines about as bad as the ones Karim was reciting earlier and Sherlock shoots out the lamp. John pipes up that they can TALK about this and work things out because he's all about that strategy suddenly. Mary asks why he wants to kill her. Ajay rambles that those people held him prisoner and he watched while they tortured Alex to death. She looks ill, but reminds him that she lost sight of HIM too. Where was he when she escaped the embassy? He says he got out just long enough to hide the memory stick so it wouldn't fall into enemy hands because HE was loyal to his friends. He keeps babbling that they weren't even torturing him for information or anything. They just thought it was fun. They were expecting him to die too and when he didn't they just grew bored and left him in a cell somewhere. For six years. At which point he escaped. Mmmkay. Sure. He says he heard them gossiping about how the smarter agents had been taken down by her though. A car drives by outside, shining a light through the window. Mary grabs her gun back from Sherlock and she and Ajay come out into the open to face off directly. Somehow, John has a gun too and is pointing it at them. Chrissy: They felt they needed to give him something to do since he's spent the last couple scenes just staring at a piece of paper and looking angsty. Mary says he knows she'll kill him. Ajay suggests he doesn't care. He's been planning how he would kill her every day for the past six years. Sherlock asks him to repeat exactly what he heard them saying while he was being held captive. Ajay entertains this plot contrivance long enough to confirm that he heard them say "ammo" a lot before refocusing on Mary to sneer that she betrayed them. Sherlock asks if they SAID it was Mary who betrayed them. Ajay says they kept saying it was the English woman. With these words, I guess his usefulness is officially ended, so some random guard guy comes in at that moment to shoot him in the back. Mary screams and she and John both check on him and we just...cut away. Back in England, Mycroft is on the phone with Sherlock, who is relaying this information. Mycroft asks if this couldn't have waited until he got back. Sherlock says no, because it's not over yet. He summarizes that the hostage takers in Georgia knew AGRA were coming because a voice on the phone told them. All they had was a female, British voice and the codeword "ammo". Sherlock finally suggests that maybe it isn't "ammo" as in "ammunition", but "amo" as in the Latin word for "love". It took Sherlock Holmes how many days to arrive at this idea? Chrissy: I see we're back on the 'he's not as smart as he thinks' argument. Diandra: No, I'm just saying. They came up with the Rachel VS German word for revenge thing RIGHT AWAY, but this never occurred to them until just now? Mycroft, even slower to pick up on this despite supposedly being the smarter one, jolts with realization, says he'd better be right and hangs up the phone. Lady Smallwood tries to swipe her access card at a panel in a government building and gets rejected. Some guys descend on her and apologetically explain that her security clearance has been temporarily suspended pending investigation. She is escorted away, the woman who was taking minutes in that first scene following her like a puppy. Sherlock, John and Mary are headed home, taking up two whole rows of seats on the plane because I guess they've found the one airline that doesn't overbook. John flashes back to that morning on the bus when a pretty girl was maybe sort of flirting with him and he found out he had a flower in his hair. This time, as the bus pulls away he realizes the woman is standing next to him. She says hi and compliments him on the daisy. John lamely jokes that it's not really him like the writers are trying not to make this about his male pride being wounded by the realization that he was wearing something effeminate but it's really not working. She says she doesn't normally do this, but...and gives him her phone number before acting all nervous and running away. John walks away a few feet maybe before having an awkward little internal argument about whether he should put the number in the contacts of his phone or (upon seeing the lock screen picture of Mary and Rosie) throw it in the nearby trash can. He winds up taking it all the way home where he continues the debate and we see that she signed the slip "E, xx". He punches the number in as a new contact and sends a text that just says "hey". He walks away, leaving the phone on the table as it buzzes with a responding "hey". Chrissy: So...what are you wearing? Diandra: Which one are you supposed to be? Chrissy: Given that we know full well where this is headed, I suppose it would make sense for me to be "E". Diandra: And what if I want to pretend I don't know where this is going and the "E" stands for Elizabeth or something? Chrissy: You're going to have to face it sooner or later, Diandra. It's a recap. Not fan fiction. Diandra: Urrrrrggggghhhhhh. You know that shopping list you made of the alcohol you need to stock up on before episode three? Chrissy: Yeah? Diandra: Double all the numbers. And then we're back to that scene where John and Mary were talking about their day and Mary called their daughter a demon spawn. This time we see the message on his phone and realize it is "E" bemoaning the fact that it's been SO long and she misses him. He looks at the clock and notes that it's really late. "Or early," she texts back. Chrissy: Really, I just woke up from a lovely wet dream about you. Diandra: .....what are you looking at me for? I thought you wanted to play both of these characters. Chrissy: Oh. Right. This is going to be like you playing both Sherlock and Mary in an argument all over again, isn't it? Diandra: Except potentially a lot more disturbing when you start the conversation like THAT. Chrissy: Okay, well. Here we go. I fantasize about tearing your clothes off with my teeth. I really shouldn't be...no, new paragraph. New paragraph. Dee, I'm talking to you, stop typing. Diandra: What? Oh... Chrissy: Sigh. Give me that. [grabs keyboard] Chrissy: I really shouldn't be doing this. I should tell you I was wearing that flower because I have a daughter and she's IN THE NEXT ROOM, but...[actual line: Night owl?] Chrissy: [actual line: Vampire.] And I want to suck you dry, if you know what I mean. Diandra: Okay, that's enough of that. [takes keyboard back] They are mercifully interrupted as Mary comes back with Rosie in her arms and passes her off to John to try to get her back to sleep. He almost leaves his phone on the night table, then takes it with him. Sometime later...maybe...I have no idea because time seems to have become relative this season...he texts that this isn't a good idea because he's taken and it will NOT go well. But hey, it's been fun. He pushes send as he gets off another bus and looks up to find her waiting at the stop. Chrissy: You don't happen to have a pet rabbit, do you? Mycroft is interrogating Lady Smallwood, who is ranting that this is ridiculous and he KNOWS it. Mycroft reminds her that she did a briefing on foreign operations six years ago under the codename "love". She spits that he's basing all of this on a whispered voice giving a CODENAME over the phone? Really? Mycroft defensively notes that she was the one giving AGRA all their assignments. She says yes, that was her job. But she sure as hell didn't betray them in Georgia. She appeals to the fact that she and Mycroft have known each other a long time and swears she has no idea what is going on here. She didn't do any of the things he's claiming she did. Mycroft looks at the one- way mirror to the side and we see Sherlock standing on the other side of it. At the Watsons, John is babbling about how he'd like to do bedtime stories with Rosie because right now all he's doing is making noises at her. She seems to like it, but... Mary says she'll have to "give that a go" and muses that she has a lot to catch up on. How long was she gone? Sherlock leaves the interrogation that went nowhere and stops on Vauxhall Bridge to ponder all the details of the case. These are all layered over a shot of the back of his head and include the comment from Mary that receptionists know everything because they hear everything. This is so completely random and seemingly unrelated to anything that it is obviously significant. He remembers Mycroft telling the woman in the corner not to take minutes in the opening scene. In case we are still not getting it, Mary repeats that "they know EVERYTHING". Sherlock takes off running. Back at the Watsons, Mary grumbles that John isn't making it easy, what with being so perfect and all. John clears his throat and says um...he needs to tell her something... Sherlock interrupts by texting them both at just that moment, instructing them to meet at the London aquarium. She says whatever it is, John will have to tell her later. Chrissy: Yeah, that's not ominous at all. Diandra: I swear I've seen this exact set up before. Chrissy: We all have. Mary realizes belatedly that they can't both go because Rosie. John tells her to go ahead and he'll join them when he's found someone to watch her. Because she's the one who needs to see whatever Sherlock has found out if it regards this case. She agrees easily. Aquarium. I would just like to take a moment to note something from one of the precious few extras related to this season because it's cute. Benedict once said that he probably has undiagnosed ADHD himself and there are times when he does an interview that I would agree. One of them was in the behind the scenes video of this scene where he kept getting distracted mid-sentence by a shark swimming past the glass like a dazzled little boy, blurting "wow" and "cool" in an awed tone. Chrissy: So Sophie has three children basically. Diandra: I'm sure she knew that going in, yes. Like millions of other women who came before her. Sherlock is walking through the glass viewing tunnel under the shark tank when a voice announces that the aquarium will be closing in five minutes. The tunnel dumps into a room where the secretary who was following Smallwood around is waiting. The woman, whose name is apparently Vivian, says this was a favorite spot of hers for agents to meet. She's looking at one of the sharks, noting that "we" are a lot like them, actually. "Ghostly. Living in the shadows." Sherlock adds "predatory". She says yeah, well...that depends on which side you're on. She belatedly adds the "we have to keep moving or we die" thing. Sherlock compliments her on her choice of location for their "final act", but acknowledges that he has a soft spot for dramatics. She says actually, she just came here to look at the fish. She says she always knew this would happen one day. It's like that story... Sherlock interrupts that he's very busy and he would like her to get to the point. She ignores him and begins the merchant story. He groans that he never liked that damned story. She's like 'good, you know it. NOW I can skip ahead' and likens herself to the merchant, thinking she could outrun "the inevitable". But she's always expected Death would find her eventually. Mary arrives just then, out of breath, and tells Sherlock John is on his way. Sherlock introduces her to "Amo", the woman who used AGRA as her personal assassination squad. Mary demands to know why she betrayed them. Sherlock guesses she was selling secrets. Vivian says yeah, well...she got a nice cottage out of it. She thought she was finished when the ambassador in Tblisi found out. But then she was taken hostage because Karma is a bitch, but she gets confused sometimes. It bought Vivian some time. Sherlock continues that she found out her boss had sent in AGRA and tipped off the hostage takers and gave them a clue about Lady Smallwood's codename. Chrissy: Um...it's not really a "clue" if you say the actual codename outright. Diandra: [gasp] Are you questioning the brilliance of the writers of this show? Chrissy: Yes. And sarcasm duly noted. "I was tired," she says. "Tired of the mess of it all." She managed to get rid of the hostages and AGRA in one fell swoop...at least she thought she did...and she assumed that her secret was buried with them. But...like the merchant...here we are. Vivian appeals to Mary that she understands what it is to just want some peace. A family. She asks them to just let her walk away and she'll just disappear. "After what you did," Mary growls and menaces toward Vivian, getting all of three steps before she pulls a gun. John is in a cab, headed toward them. Vivian muses that she was never an agent, but she always thought she'd make a pretty good one. Mary snorts. Sherlock notes that she handled the situation in Tblisi pretty well for a secretary. "Can't have been easy all those years, sitting in the back, keeping your mouth shut when you knew you were cleverer than most of the people in the room." Vivian splutters that he thinks this is about simple jealousy. Sherlock adjusts his assessment a little to note that she must have been bored with the daily "drudge" and wished she could go out into the field. Chrissy: Just because you and John get off on danger doesn't mean the rest of the world does. He adds an unnecessary detail that he knows by the clay on her shoes where she lives and that area is full of tiny little boring flats. She spent all the money she got from her treachery on that cottage and the state of her wedding ring tells him she's widowed. Also, she has a lot of cats. Mary tries to reign Sherlock in despite being the one whose hotheadedness got Vivian to draw the gun in the first place. He ignores her and keeps outlining how sad and lonely she must be to be spending her Friday nights in an aquarium. Also she has a drinking problem. In conclusion, yes she did it out of jealousy. "To prove how good you are. To make up for the inadequacies of your little life." Mycroft shows up just then, followed by Lestrade and a couple other guys, and notes that this is "unexpected". Also, he gives us her full name: Vivian Norbury. She smirks, suggests that she might still be able to surprise Sherlock, raises the gun and fires at him. Everything goes into slow motion, except Mary who somehow manages to jump in front of the bullet in time despite not moving until a full second after the gun went off. Because physics works differently in this universe this season. Sherlock crouches beside Mary and assures her that everything will be fine. Then he orders Mycroft to get an ambulance, which he does without argument. John arrives just then so he never sees what, exactly, happened. He takes Sherlock's place and starts spewing the usual nonsense like "stay with me". She sneers that he can do better than that. Chrissy: Always have to have the last word, don't you? You really are just like Sherlock. Diandra: Yeah, well, that EXPLAINS A LOT. She says this is it and proceeds to babble through tears about how happy he's made her and makes him promise to take good care of their daughter. Then she turns to Sherlock and says she always liked him and she's sorry about shooting him that one time but she's pretty sure they're even now. That may very well be one of the weirdest sentences I've ever typed. She refocuses on John and thanks him for the time she was Mary Watson because it was the only part of her life that was really worthwhile. And then she goes still as she's saying "thank you" and John checks her pulse and slowly breaks down into a sort of scream crying that sounds like a water buffalo in heat. Chrissy: How would you even know what that sounds like? Diandra: Well, how would you describe that? Chrissy: Eh. Probably a wookie vomiting or something. Diandra: I feel like this recap is in serious danger of devolving. Then Sherlock kind of tentatively reaches for his shoulder and he looks up, furious, and snaps at him to back off because he made a VOW. Again, I'm kind of paraphrasing because the actual line is much dumber. I seriously don't know what happened this season. We get some artsy bullshit of sharks swimming and Vivian being led to her new cell and Mary being possibly cremated. Martin spends another few minutes of screen time staring into space and saying nothing while a phone buzzes in the background. And then we're with his therapist from the first couple seasons, except she has a different office now. She's talking about recurring dreams and repeatedly prompting who we are clearly supposed to assume is John to talk to her about it. "The whole world has come crashing down around you. Everything is hopeless. Irretrievable." Chrissy: Remind me how much I'm paying you to make me feel better again? She says she can only help if he opens up to her. The camera backs up enough that we can see curly hair and realize she's actually talking to Sherlock before he says yeah, um...not really the kind of thing he does. He just needs to know what to do about John. Chrissy: And I'm pretty sure the tin hat people have written volumes on how the oddness of this scene is proof that it isn't real. Diandra: Well, it is pretty weird in the sense that it appears to be taking place in the attic of a church. Seriously, what is with this set? Mycroft goes home, stares forlornly into his refrigerator like he's just remembering he ate the last of the cake already and there's nothing else in there that looks good. He closes it and plucks a chinese take out menu from the array on the front, revealing a post-it that says "13th". He hesitates, then pulls out his phone and orders somebody to put him through to "Sherrinford". Fans of the original Doyle stories perk up at the name of the hypothetical third eldest brother that was invented to explain why Sherlock and Mycroft were able to forgo Victorian traditions regarding family responsibilities. Chrissy: Ah. Remember back when we thought this plot point would prove to actually make sense or have anything to do with the original stories whatsoever? Wasn't that nice? Diandra: How naive we were then. And we're back in 221b. Sherlock is sitting in his chair and Mrs. Hudson is in John's. The red balloon John stand in is hanging limply off the little table beside John's chair. Mrs. Hudson is crying and moaning that nothing is going to be the same anymore, is it? Chrissy: That's what we're afraid of, yes. Mrs. Hudson says they'll have to "rally" a bit and all look after Rosie. Sherlock, getting uncomfortable with this conversation, jumps up to look through the crap on the table for a possible case. Mrs. Hudson doesn't think he could possibly be up to solving a case right now. Hi. Have you two met? Sherlock grumbles that work is "the best antidote to sorrow". Er. No, I'm pretty sure it's a way of ignoring the sorrow. You throw yourself into it so you don't have to think about what happened because otherwise you might spend all day in bed crying and reopening the wounds over and over. Mrs. Hudson offers the other British answer to any and all problems: some tea. Sherlock doesn't look at her as he says "if you ever think I'm becoming a bit full of myself, cocky or overconfident would you just say the word Norbury to me?" Okay. So this is one of those times where the writers make a reference to an original Doyle story that is technically right, but the context is completely changed and not necessarily for the better. "The Adventure of the Yellow Face" was one of my favorite stories. It was about a woman keeping her mixed race daughter from a previous marriage secret from her new husband, fearing he would reject her. When the boys revealed the deception to the husband, however, he welcomed the child with open arms and told his wife that he may not be the greatest man, but he might be better than she gives him credit for (i.e. the line Mofftiss gave John a few scenes back in an entirely different context). Holmes was so moved by it that he gave Watson similar instructions when they got home. I have no idea what to make of this altered version of one of the better moments of the canon as far as I'm concerned. I mean...it's basically the same instructions, just given to a different character, but... Chrissy: Not as humbling? Diandra: Maybe? Mrs. Hudson is like 'uh...okay...whatever that means...sure.' Then Sherlock finds a package on the table and she remembers that she brought it up because she found it mixed up with her stuff. Sherlock pulls a disc out of the package that is labeled "MISS ME?" Mrs. Hudson jumps and asks "is that..." "Must be," Sherlock interrupts. He babbles that he KNEW Moriarty had made plans and it wasn't really over. Why are we so certain of that? Where are the writers getting this conviction that Moriarty must be involved in more than he ever was in the canon? Chrissy: Because he's a fan favorite? Diandra: Ugh. I don't know how many times I've argued with idiots claiming he MUST still be alive despite being shot in the head. HE'S DEAD. He's already been more involved than his namesake ever was. LET HIM GO ALREADY. Sherlock loads the disc in the laptop and a video of Mary pops up. "Thought that would get your attention," she smirks. She launches into the standard 'if you're watching this it means I'm dead' set up. She acknowledges that her former life was dangerous and full of consequences that she knew she couldn't outrun forever and Sherlock should KEEP THAT IN MIND. She takes a breath and says she's giving Sherlock a case and it might be his most difficult. When she dies, she needs him to do something. We cut away before we can see the rest of that because for some reason this video is shown in small pieces scattered throughout this season and it makes a little less sense each time. Sherlock goes to the Watson's house, which apparently has an entrance under a staircase. Molly comes out with Rosie in her arms. Sherlock awkwardly says he was just...um... seeing how things are going...um...and if there's anything he can do. Molly hands him a letter from John and tells him he doesn't need to read it right now. She apologetically adds that her instructions were if Sherlock came around offering to help that she should tell him he'd rather have ANYONE ELSE. She slinks back into the house. In voice over, Mary repeats that she needs him to do something for her: save John Watson. Sherlock walks around London sullenly, his own voice over rambling about destiny and traps and death awaiting us all in Samarra. "But can Samarra be avoided?" Credits. And if you stayed through the credits because, like me, you were too busy asking yourself when the HELL this show became so bleak to locate the stop button on the remote, you noticed that Mary cut in again to say "Go to hell, Sherlock." Chrissy: Yes, that sounds more like her. Also, anyone who is a fan of Marvel knows to stay to the end of the credits, Dee. Diandra: Oh, right. Chrissy: Speaking of which, maybe we should take a break from this and go do that "Avengers" recap now because I think it might be a lot more fun. Diandra: Right behind you.